Explore More: Check Your $2 Bills — They Could Be Worth a Ton The 1864 Indian Head penny has an “L” on the ribbon behind the Indian Head and next to the bottom feather. A coin in good ...

These coins can range in price from $4,500 up to $172,500. 8. 1864 Indian Head Penny “L” on Ribbon — $161,000 After Flying Eagle Cent was minted, the federal government transitioned to the ...